Lora's Latest Post

Is the Third Time the Charm?

Within SAP, there are many ways to implement a Sales and Operations Planning (S&OP) process (cobbling together components).  I can think of four and with the new release of SAP’s new S&OP product, I think that we now have five.

Background

With the release of their new S&OP Hana product, it is an exciting time for SAP; and, I think a tipping point for the S&OP market.  Let me explain…
This is SAP’s third attempt to launch a S&OP solution.  As Hans Thalbauer, SVP Line of Business Solutions, presents the keynote for tomorrow morning’s session, the question for many attendees in the audience is “Will the third time be the charm?”  They will question, “Will this S&OP release actually work?’
No one really knows the final answer.  The product is early in its testing (Beta testing with five pilot customers) and I expect it to be expensive (although there is no official pricing).  However,  I like some of the product’s features and SAP is working hard to make is successful:

  1. Hosted Solution.  It is SAP’s first off-premise, hosted supply chain application, and it was developed on the much touted HANA platform.
  2. What-if Analysis.  The business promise is quick visualization of the supply chain for executive review and the use of what-if analysis using the HANA engine for parallel processing.  The technology is one of two S&OP platforms (Kinaxis and Steelwedge) in the market with a specially architected data model just for S&OP.
  3. Collaborative Interface.  The solution uses Streamworks to promote discussion of workgroups in the development of the S&OP process. While it is one of the first products to use an enteprise social collaboration tool, the functionality is very basic and lacks the the deeper functionality of Lithium or Jive, but is a stronger tool than Yammer.

However, as SAP rolls out the product, the positioning needs to be VERY CLEAR.  Today, it is not.  The presentation at the SAP CVN given to customers was vague and there was no direct answer to the attendees’ questions on how the new solution fits with other SAP products.  Even internally within SAP, I sense a debate.

 Why is this Interesting?

As supply chains have grown more complex, and outside-in, I think that there is a need for a specially architected solution for S&OP that sits above the traditional Advanced Planning (APS) footprint. I also think that there is a need for a S&OP execution tool to track the prior period’s plan and look at the validity of the assumptions.
Both are important. The need for a data model and supply chain visualization for S&OP has grown in importance.  My perspective on this requirement has changed dramatically over the last year.  With the Merger and Acquisition (M&A) flurry, 65% of companies now have multiple S&OP processes, layered over their multiple APS systems (could be multiple forms of SAP APO).  With these multiple S&OP processes, there is a need for demand translation (translation from channel to manufacturing logic and translation across multiple equivalent units). There is also a need for what-if analysis for risk management and balancing of the external supply chain. Today, business users are frustrated with the lack of what-if planning tools and the visualization of the plans to drive action.
We are seeing the creation of a new category of applications for S&OP.  For the last fifteen years, S&OP processes were supported by  traditional APS solutions.  There was a single process and a central planning department.  S&OP was simply an extension of this original APS investment.  However, for complex supply chains, it is no longer sufficient to morph demand and supply planning solutions for S&OP.  The only other S&OP platform designed for S&OP in today’s market is Steelwedge.  The SAP S&OP product is now a direct competitor for the Steelwedge product.

The Shaman’s Take

The questions in the two sessions have been largely the same.  Here I share the question, and the response that I gave.
Does this mean that we no longer need SAP APO to support the S&OP process?
The SAP S&OP tool delivers against four principle benefits:  what if analysis, visualization of options for the executive S&OP meeting, demand translation and execution tracking of the S&OP plan (e.g. how effective was the S&OP plan for the last period).  However, the tool does not have the depth of optimization for manufacturing constraint analysis, determination of inventory strategies or the ability to determine the best constrained forecast.  Since more than 95% of manufacturers have constraints, there are few companies that will be able to use this new SAP  S&OP technology in place of an APS technology like SAP APO product.
What about inventory optimization?  Do we still need an inventory optimization tool to support the S&OP process or is this product’s functionality sufficient?
Yes, companies should continue to use inventory  optimization technologies with their S&OP processes. While the new product can be populated with inventory data, it lacks optimization to determine the form and function of inventory in the supply chain.
What about the integration of this product to corporate financials?  Is this an Integrated Business Planning product?
SAP is attempting to fill this niche, but for me the jury is still out.  The financial integration of this product is new and evolving.  I expect for SAP to enrich this over time, but I think that there are still a lot of learnings to happen in this area.  I would not recommend SAP’s S&OP product for financial integration of the S&OP process at this time.
I have SAP APO, why do I need this new product for S&OP?
For companies with increasing complexity, this product  enables visualization, what if analysis and reporting.  All three have been major complaints by SAP users.

Wrap-up

So, for SAP, will this third try be a charm?  It is too  early to tell, but the release is promising.  Since I come from the “show  me state” I am still waiting to speak to “real companies” driving value before I give it a definitive thumbs up.  Today’s pilots and testing of the product while promising, are not  a full-scale test.
The ideal adopter is a SAP client with strong  analytical skills and S&OP maturity. It needs more testing, but it is  promising.  The third try just might be a charm, but until the SHAMAN talks to a real customer gaining real value, she is holding her charm bracelet in her hand.
What do  you think?  Any experience with SAP HANA S&OP to share with the readers?
 
 

Search the Archives
Search
Share this Post
Email
Twitter
LinkedIn
Facebook
Pinterest
WhatsApp
Featured Image
Recent Posts

Defining the Role of the Budget in Supply Chain Planning

A financial budget is not an operational plan, and the two should be connected without confusing financial compliance with enterprise value optimization. Achieving alignment requires leadership, trust, shared incentives, and a common understanding of how market changes, product mix, capacity, and operational decisions affect financial outcomes. Technology is the easy part; the real challenge is overcoming functional silos and enabling finance and supply chain to collaborate on trade-offs and business outcomes. AI, LLMs, and context graphs can help bridge the gap by making interdependencies visible, improving cross-functional understanding, and supporting better enterprise decisions.

Read More »

AI Defining a Middle Ground Between Custom and Packaged Applications in Supply Chain Planning

Supply chain planning has evolved technologically, but its underlying processes remain rooted in historic practices that no longer fit today’s volatile, complex environment. Packaged applications promise faster, lower-cost, lower-risk business outcomes, yet extensive customization, fragmented data, and rigid workflows often undermine that promise. Cloud data and AI platforms like Databricks and Snowflake offer an alternative: build interoperable applications on top of existing planning systems to address gaps in direct procurement, plan consumption, bullwhip reduction, operational planning, and dynamic master data. The opportunity is not simply to automate existing processes with AI and agentics, but to redefine how work gets done through end-to-end orchestration, value-based trade-offs, and clear decision governance.

Read More »

Reflection and Celebration for the Supply Chains to Admire Methodology

The Supply Chains to Admire to is an objective, data-driven standard for measuring supply chain excellence and moves beyond industry reputation, anecdotal evidence, and technology claims. Using revenue growth, operating margin, inventory turns, and return on invested capital (ROCE, the research evaluates how companies perform relative to industry peers over time. Here Lora shares information on an upcoming event to celebrate the Supply Chains to Admire Award Winners.

Read More »

Five Things I Don’t Understand

Solutions that we never imagined years ago are emergining, but I pause when companies are unwilling or unable to roll up their sleeves and redefine work. Historic practices are not best practices, and there is a wealth of opportunity for those that do challenge the existing status quo. .

Read More »